Pass the values of the MotionEvent instead of the event instance itself

to BackAnimation.

The original MotionEvent instance may have been recycled by the time BackAnimation processes it, since BackAnimation runs in a different thread. This could cause crashes from both Java side and native side, as described in b/233163975#comment11.

We work around this by passing the numerical values that BackAnimation
need instead of the MotionEvent itself.

Test: Swipe back in various scenarios. Make sure back can be triggered.
Try cancel. Make sure back can be cancelled.
Test: atest BackAnimationControllerTest
Bug: 233163975

Change-Id: I4792debc705536b49d1caafcc43e5466941c1d43
This commit is contained in:
Shan Huang
2022-06-16 21:57:33 -07:00
parent 94f1ce550f
commit f89eb1e5b5
5 changed files with 23 additions and 19 deletions

View File

@@ -31,13 +31,15 @@ public interface BackAnimation {
/** /**
* Called when a {@link MotionEvent} is generated by a back gesture. * Called when a {@link MotionEvent} is generated by a back gesture.
* *
* @param event the original {@link MotionEvent} * @param touchX the X touch position of the {@link MotionEvent}.
* @param action the original {@link KeyEvent#getAction()} when the event was dispatched to * @param touchY the Y touch position of the {@link MotionEvent}.
* @param keyAction the original {@link KeyEvent#getAction()} when the event was dispatched to
* the process. This is forwarded separately because the input pipeline may mutate * the process. This is forwarded separately because the input pipeline may mutate
* the {#event} action state later. * the {#event} action state later.
* @param swipeEdge the edge from which the swipe begins. * @param swipeEdge the edge from which the swipe begins.
*/ */
void onBackMotion(MotionEvent event, int action, @BackEvent.SwipeEdge int swipeEdge); void onBackMotion(float touchX, float touchY, int keyAction,
@BackEvent.SwipeEdge int swipeEdge);
/** /**
* Sets whether the back gesture is past the trigger threshold or not. * Sets whether the back gesture is past the trigger threshold or not.

View File

@@ -184,8 +184,8 @@ public class BackAnimationController implements RemoteCallable<BackAnimationCont
@Override @Override
public void onBackMotion( public void onBackMotion(
MotionEvent event, int action, @BackEvent.SwipeEdge int swipeEdge) { float touchX, float touchY, int keyAction, @BackEvent.SwipeEdge int swipeEdge) {
mShellExecutor.execute(() -> onMotionEvent(event, action, swipeEdge)); mShellExecutor.execute(() -> onMotionEvent(touchX, touchY, keyAction, swipeEdge));
} }
@Override @Override
@@ -256,33 +256,34 @@ public class BackAnimationController implements RemoteCallable<BackAnimationCont
* Called when a new motion event needs to be transferred to this * Called when a new motion event needs to be transferred to this
* {@link BackAnimationController} * {@link BackAnimationController}
*/ */
public void onMotionEvent(MotionEvent event, int action, @BackEvent.SwipeEdge int swipeEdge) { public void onMotionEvent(float touchX, float touchY, int keyAction,
@BackEvent.SwipeEdge int swipeEdge) {
if (mTransitionInProgress) { if (mTransitionInProgress) {
return; return;
} }
if (action == MotionEvent.ACTION_MOVE) { if (keyAction == MotionEvent.ACTION_MOVE) {
if (!mBackGestureStarted) { if (!mBackGestureStarted) {
// Let the animation initialized here to make sure the onPointerDownOutsideFocus // Let the animation initialized here to make sure the onPointerDownOutsideFocus
// could be happened when ACTION_DOWN, it may change the current focus that we // could be happened when ACTION_DOWN, it may change the current focus that we
// would access it when startBackNavigation. // would access it when startBackNavigation.
initAnimation(event); initAnimation(touchX, touchY);
} }
onMove(event, swipeEdge); onMove(touchX, touchY, swipeEdge);
} else if (action == MotionEvent.ACTION_UP || action == MotionEvent.ACTION_CANCEL) { } else if (keyAction == MotionEvent.ACTION_UP || keyAction == MotionEvent.ACTION_CANCEL) {
ProtoLog.d(WM_SHELL_BACK_PREVIEW, ProtoLog.d(WM_SHELL_BACK_PREVIEW,
"Finishing gesture with event action: %d", action); "Finishing gesture with event action: %d", keyAction);
onGestureFinished(); onGestureFinished();
} }
} }
private void initAnimation(MotionEvent event) { private void initAnimation(float touchX, float touchY) {
ProtoLog.d(WM_SHELL_BACK_PREVIEW, "initAnimation mMotionStarted=%b", mBackGestureStarted); ProtoLog.d(WM_SHELL_BACK_PREVIEW, "initAnimation mMotionStarted=%b", mBackGestureStarted);
if (mBackGestureStarted || mBackNavigationInfo != null) { if (mBackGestureStarted || mBackNavigationInfo != null) {
Log.e(TAG, "Animation is being initialized but is already started."); Log.e(TAG, "Animation is being initialized but is already started.");
finishAnimation(); finishAnimation();
} }
mInitTouchLocation.set(event.getX(), event.getY()); mInitTouchLocation.set(touchX, touchY);
mBackGestureStarted = true; mBackGestureStarted = true;
try { try {
@@ -351,18 +352,18 @@ public class BackAnimationController implements RemoteCallable<BackAnimationCont
mTransaction.setVisibility(screenshotSurface, true); mTransaction.setVisibility(screenshotSurface, true);
} }
private void onMove(MotionEvent event, @BackEvent.SwipeEdge int swipeEdge) { private void onMove(float touchX, float touchY, @BackEvent.SwipeEdge int swipeEdge) {
if (!mBackGestureStarted || mBackNavigationInfo == null) { if (!mBackGestureStarted || mBackNavigationInfo == null) {
return; return;
} }
int deltaX = Math.round(event.getX() - mInitTouchLocation.x); int deltaX = Math.round(touchX - mInitTouchLocation.x);
float progressThreshold = PROGRESS_THRESHOLD >= 0 ? PROGRESS_THRESHOLD : mProgressThreshold; float progressThreshold = PROGRESS_THRESHOLD >= 0 ? PROGRESS_THRESHOLD : mProgressThreshold;
float progress = Math.min(Math.max(Math.abs(deltaX) / progressThreshold, 0), 1); float progress = Math.min(Math.max(Math.abs(deltaX) / progressThreshold, 0), 1);
int backType = mBackNavigationInfo.getType(); int backType = mBackNavigationInfo.getType();
RemoteAnimationTarget animationTarget = mBackNavigationInfo.getDepartingAnimationTarget(); RemoteAnimationTarget animationTarget = mBackNavigationInfo.getDepartingAnimationTarget();
BackEvent backEvent = new BackEvent( BackEvent backEvent = new BackEvent(
event.getX(), event.getY(), progress, swipeEdge, animationTarget); touchX, touchY, progress, swipeEdge, animationTarget);
IOnBackInvokedCallback targetCallback = null; IOnBackInvokedCallback targetCallback = null;
if (shouldDispatchToLauncher(backType)) { if (shouldDispatchToLauncher(backType)) {
targetCallback = mBackToLauncherCallback; targetCallback = mBackToLauncherCallback;

View File

@@ -298,7 +298,7 @@ public class BackAnimationControllerTest {
private void doMotionEvent(int actionDown, int coordinate) { private void doMotionEvent(int actionDown, int coordinate) {
mController.onMotionEvent( mController.onMotionEvent(
MotionEvent.obtain(0, mEventTime, actionDown, coordinate, coordinate, 0), coordinate, coordinate,
actionDown, actionDown,
BackEvent.EDGE_LEFT); BackEvent.EDGE_LEFT);
mEventTime += 10; mEventTime += 10;

View File

@@ -291,7 +291,8 @@ class BackPanelController private constructor(
override fun onMotionEvent(event: MotionEvent) { override fun onMotionEvent(event: MotionEvent) {
backAnimation?.onBackMotion( backAnimation?.onBackMotion(
event, event.x,
event.y,
event.actionMasked, event.actionMasked,
if (mView.isLeftPanel) BackEvent.EDGE_LEFT else BackEvent.EDGE_RIGHT if (mView.isLeftPanel) BackEvent.EDGE_LEFT else BackEvent.EDGE_RIGHT
) )

View File

@@ -486,7 +486,7 @@ public class NavigationBarEdgePanel extends View implements NavigationEdgeBackPl
public void onMotionEvent(MotionEvent event) { public void onMotionEvent(MotionEvent event) {
if (mBackAnimation != null) { if (mBackAnimation != null) {
mBackAnimation.onBackMotion( mBackAnimation.onBackMotion(
event, event.getX(), event.getY(),
event.getActionMasked(), event.getActionMasked(),
mIsLeftPanel ? BackEvent.EDGE_LEFT : BackEvent.EDGE_RIGHT); mIsLeftPanel ? BackEvent.EDGE_LEFT : BackEvent.EDGE_RIGHT);
} }